12 of the Best Leftover Halloween Candy Recipes

Mama on the Homestead participates in the Amazon Services LLC Affiliate Program. This allows me to make a small commission on goods you purchase through my links. Thank you!

Check out these candy recipes to use up leftover Halloween candy!

Happy Halloween, Y’all! It’s time for tricks, treats, and sugar-fueled kiddos… Are you ready for that? Of course not! But it is happening so you might as well roll with it, right?

If you live in an area with high trick-or-treat traffic then you better stock up on bags of Halloween candy….most people stock up even if trick-or-treaters never darken their doorstep…I mean, why pass up on an opportunity to buy a ton of candy without judgment? Your home might be totally candy free by the end of the night, but what in the name of pumpkin spice are you going to do if you have leftover Halloween candy that even Netflix sugar-binge nights can’t use up?

Will you save it for next Easter’s “stale candy” eggs? Don’t be that lady 😉 Instead, try out one (or all) of these yummy leftover Halloween Candy Recipes!

Leftover Halloween Candy Recipes

1. Candy Corn Bark – This Gal Cooks

12 Recipes for Leftover Halloween Candy | Faithful Farmwife | This Gal Cooks

Candy Corn catches a lot of flak, but even the Candy Corn haters can get on board with this yummy, 4-ingredient, white chocolate bark!

2. Butterfinger Cream Pie – Just a Pinch

Butterfingers & Pie….Two delicious faves combine to make this creamy treat! You could make this with other leftover candy bars, too, if you are a little short on Butterfingers:)

3. Popcorn Hands – Yummy Healthy Easy

This super simple treat is perfect for your leftover popcorn and the kids will get a kick out of it! Throw in some candy corn or m&ms for a little extra flare!

12 Recipes for Leftover Halloween Candy | Faithful Farmwife | Yummy Healthy Easy

4. Candy Bar Brownies – Love From the Oven

Have lots of leftover Halloween candy bars? Throw them in with some brownie batter and enjoy!

12 Recipes for Leftover Halloween Candy | Faithful Farmwife | Love From the Oven
5. Deep Fried Mini Snickers Bars – Ashlee Marie

12 Recipes for Leftover Halloween Candy | Faithful Farmwife | Ashlee Marie

In the South, we love EVERYTHING deep fried. So, seriously…Does this one even need a caption? Deep.Fried.Snickers…’nuff said.

6. Skittles Rainbow Fudge– Lemon Tree Dwelling

Let’s not let chocolate hog the spotlight… Taste the rainbow with this yummy skittles fudge!

12 Recipes for Leftover Halloween Candy | Faithful Farmwife | Lemon Tree Dwelling

7. Snickers Cheesecake– Basil & Bubbly

Not a cheesecake lover? I bet the addition of some Snickers and caramel sauce might change your mind 🙂

Cookie cakes are a favorite of mine and this one makes my mouth water! Add any chocolate candies that you have stored away for a delectable treat!

9. Reeses Peanut Butter Cupcakes– Crazy Little Projects

My husband and I *might* have our children believing in a “candy tax” that can be paid for with Reeses cups… I think we might have to turn them into stuffed cupcakes this year!

10. Edible Starburst Slime– Teach Beside Me

Mix it up a little with edible candy slime! Fun & tasty!

11. Stuffed Snickerdoodle Cookies– Yellow Bliss Road

Stuff these cookies with soft caramels or Rollos for a sweet treat!

12. Chocolate Peanut Butter Kit Kat Crunch Bars– Averie Cooks

12 Recipes for Leftover Halloween Candy | Faithful Farmwife

Oh.My.Yum!! Gimme a break, gimme a break, gimme a break of that Chocolate Peanut Butter Kit Kat Crunch bar!!

>>More Sweet Recipes You Might Like<<

Pin “12 Recipes for Leftover Halloween Candy Recipes” for Later!


4 Simple Fall Art Projects for Kids
14+ Horse Birthday Party Ideas for Your Little Cowgirl

Similar Posts


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *